Shop
Home

How To Choose The Best Stool For Your Kitchen Island

Shop the Post
Baxton Studio Sofia Modern Wood Counter Stool
POLY & BARK Weave Counter Stool
Safavieh Home Collection Fremont Natural Barstool
KOUBOO Chippendale Rattan Barstool
Ball & Cast Kitchen Island Woven Bar Stools Counter Height
PURPLE LEAF French Counter Height Bar Stool Set of 2
EALSON Counter Height Bar Stools Set of 2
Bar Stools Set of 2, Counter Height
25.9-inch Woven Rope Bar Stool
Set of 2 Natural Rattan Bar Stools Counter Stool
Nathan James Bailey Upholstered Rattan Bar Stool
Duhome Wood Bar Stools Set of 2
Counter Height Bar Stools

Choosing the best stool for your kitchen island can make a big impact in your kitchen. Not only do you need to make sure you have the correct height for comfort, but you’ll also want to have kitchen stools that are aesthetically pleasing.

Let’s examine how to choose the best stool for your kitchen island.

This post may contain affiliate links.

How To Choose The Best Stool For Your Kitchen Island Natural Stools

How To Choose The Best Stool For Your Kitchen Island

The kitchen is the heart of the home. 

If you have a kitchen island, you likely have a spot for seating around it and want to be able to fit the entire family. Oftentimes, this is where some of the best conversations happen, so you want it to be comfortable and inviting.

When it comes to kitchen islands, having the right stools can make all the difference. 

Not only do stools provide seating and functionality, but they also contribute to the overall aesthetic of your kitchen.

With so many options available, choosing the best stool for your kitchen island can seem like a tricky task. However, with a little guidance, you can find the perfect kitchen island stools that combine style, comfort, and practicality.

 Here are some tips to help you make the right decision.

The best kitchen stool with baby in a high chair and natural chairs

Measure Your Space

Before you start shopping for the best stool for your kitchen island, measure the height of your kitchen island or counter. This measurement will help you determine the appropriate stool height for a comfortable seating experience.

 As a general rule of thumb, there should be about 9-13 inches between the seat of the stool and the bottom of the counter.

Bar stools suitable for standard kitchen islands come in different heights. Typically, they have a seat height of 24 to 26 inches. This height is compatible with kitchen counters that are around 36 inches high.

 For taller kitchen islands or bar counters measuring around 42 inches in height, taller seating with a bar stool height of 28 to 30 inches are more appropriate.

Backless stool

Consider Style and Material

Stools come in a variety of styles and materials, so choose one that complements your kitchen decor. 

Whether you prefer modern, rustic, industrial, or traditional styles, there are stools to match every taste. 

Consider different materials like solid wood, metal, or upholstered seats based on your preferences and the existing design of your kitchen.

Natural rattan kitchen stool

Styles To Consider

  1. Traditional: Classic wooden bar stools with simple designs can add a timeless touch to your kitchen island.
  2. Modern: Sleek metal or plastic bar stools with clean lines and minimalist aesthetics can complement a contemporary kitchen space.
  3. Industrial: Bar stools featuring metal frames, rustic finishes, and raw materials can bring an industrial vibe to your kitchen.
  4. Upholstered: Bar stools with padded seats and backs offer comfort and can introduce texture and various colors to the kitchen.

Materials To Consider

  1. Wood: Wooden stools provide a warm and inviting look to the kitchen. They come in various finishes and styles, ranging from traditional to modern.
  2. Metal: Metal bar stools offer a sleek and contemporary design. They are durable, easy to clean, and can add an industrial touch to the kitchen.
  3. Upholstered: Upholstered bar stools provide extra comfort and a soft texture. They come in a variety of fabrics and color options, allowing for customization to match your kitchen decor.
  4. Rattan or Wicker: Rattan or wicker bar stools bring a natural and casual vibe to the kitchen. They are lightweight and great for creating a laid-back atmosphere.
How to choose the besst stool for your kitchen island with white kitchen and natural stool

Think About Functionality

Think about how you plan to use the stools. Will they be used for quick meals, casual dining, or as extra seating when entertaining guests? 

Adjustable height stools can provide versatility for different uses, while 360-degree swivel stools make it easy to turn and chat with others in the kitchen.

The best kitchen counter stools will serve a dual purpose: they’ll be a comfortable place to sit and also an extension of your kitchen’s design.

Mudroom art room and backless stools

 If your kitchen island doubles as a food preparation area and a dining table, consider counter height stools with a low-back design that can easily tuck under the island to save space but still provide back support when seated. 

A sleek bar stool with a simple design can be a great addition to a modern style kitchen, offering a clean aesthetic without overwhelming your space.

For islands that serve as an eat-in kitchen or a home bar, bar height stools with high backs and an upholstered seat cushion might be the better option, as they offer more support for longer periods of sitting. 

If your kitchen opens up to an outdoor entertaining area, consider durable bar stools that can transition between indoor and outdoor use.

Rattan stools. and rattan vase

Comfort Is Key

Since you and your family will likely spend a fair amount of time sitting on the stools, comfort is essential. 

Look for stools with supportive backs, footrests, and cushioned seats for added comfort. Swivel stools and stools with armrests can also enhance comfort and convenience.

Comfort is a key factor to consider when choosing the best bar stools for your kitchen island because you want your seating to be not only stylish but also enjoyable and functional.

 Here are some important aspects of comfort to keep in mind:

Natural stools with white kitchen

Seat Height

Ensure that the height of the bar stools allows for comfortable seating at the kitchen island. The distance between the seat of the bar stool and the countertop should provide enough legroom and support for the person seated.

Seat Size & Shape

Choose bar stools with an appropriate seat size and shape that accommodate the user comfortably. A wide and contoured seat can provide better support and comfort, especially for longer periods of sitting.

Backrest & Armrests

Consider whether you prefer bar stools with low backs, high backs, or armrests for added comfort and support. Backrests provide lumbar support, while armrests can help reduce strain on the arms and shoulders.

Bernedoodle in kitchen with white and natural accents

Cushioning

Opt for bar stools with cushioned seats for enhanced comfort. Upholstered bar stools or those with seat pads can provide a softer seating surface and make extended sitting more pleasant.

Footrest

A footrest is essential for supporting the legs and providing a comfortable sitting posture. It helps reduce pressure on the lower back and promotes better circulation while seated.

Swivel Function

Swivel bar stools offer added comfort and convenience, allowing for easy movement and adjustment while seated. They can also facilitate conversations and interactions in a kitchen or dining area.

Stability & Durability

Choose bar stools that are sturdy and well-constructed to ensure stability and safety while seated. A wobbly or flimsy bar stool can be uncomfortable and unsafe to use.

Natural kitchen stool in white kitchen
If you love the look of natural wood, these kitchen stools are perfect for this white and natural aesthetic.

Number Of Stools

Consider how many stools you will need for your kitchen island. 

The size of your island and the size of your space will dictate how many stools can comfortably fit. Leave enough floor space between each stool for people to sit comfortably without feeling cramped.

The number of bar stools you choose for your kitchen island is an important consideration when selecting the best seating options for your seating space. Here’s why the number of stools matters:

How To Choose The Best Stool For Your Kitchen Island Woven leather kitchen stool
I love the look of a woven leather kitchen stool in a natural color to offset the darker island.

Seating Capacity

The number of bar stools you select should correspond to the size of your kitchen island and the number of people you want to accommodate. 

Ensure there is enough space between each stool for comfortable seating and easy movement around the island.

Balance & Symmetry

Choosing the right number of bar stools helps maintain balance and symmetry in your kitchen design. 

An odd number of seats can create a more casual and dynamic look, while even numbers often provide a more formal and balanced appearance.

Functionality

Having the appropriate number of bar stools ensures that your kitchen island seating is functional and practical for everyday use. It allows family members and guests to gather comfortably for meals, conversations, or other activities in the kitchen.

How To Choose The Best Stool For Your Kitchen Island with Wishbone kitchen stools
These wishbone kitchen stools look familiar!

Space Constraints

Consider the size of your kitchen and the available space around the island when determining the number of bar stools. Avoid overcrowding the area with too many stools, which can make it feel cramped and hinder movement.

Aesthetics

The number of bar stools you choose can impact the overall aesthetic of your kitchen. Selecting the right quantity can enhance the visual appeal and balance of the space, contributing to a cohesive and well-designed look.

Rattan kitchen stool with white and wood accent kitchen
I love these rattan kitchen stools in this white and wood accent kitchen. So pretty!

Quality & Durability

Invest in high-quality stools that are built to last. 

Look for sturdy construction, durable materials, and a reputable brand known for producing long-lasting furniture, like Pottery Barn or West Elm. 

Quality stools may have a higher price point upfront but will save you money in the long run by not having to replace them frequently.

Quality and durability are crucial factors to consider when choosing the best bar stools for your kitchen island. 

Here are some of the reasons why they are important:

Woven leather kitchen stool
This is another beautiful kitchen with woven leather stools.

Longevity

Investing in high-quality bar stools ensures that they will last for a long time, reducing the need for frequent replacements. Durable materials and solid construction contribute to the longevity of the bar stools.

Stability & Safety

Quality bar stools are built to be stable and sturdy, providing a safe seating option for you and your guests. Ensuring that the bar stools are durable helps prevent accidents or injuries that may occur due to unstable seating.

Usage & Maintenance

Bar stools in the kitchen are often subject to frequent use, spills, and messes. 

Opting for durable materials that are easy to clean and maintain will help preserve the appearance and functionality of the bar stools over time. This is something I always think about with four kids!

Traditional kitchen with white and light wood accent
These traditional kitchen stools are beautiful in this all white kitchen.

Comfort

High-quality bar stools are typically designed with comfort in mind, incorporating features such as ergonomic seats, supportive backrests, and appropriate cushioning. 

Comfortable seating enhances the overall dining and socializing experience at the kitchen island.

Aesthetics

Quality bar stools are often crafted with attention to detail and craftsmanship, leading to a more polished and attractive appearance. 

Well-made bar stools can elevate the aesthetic appeal of your kitchen and contribute to a cohesive design scheme.

White kitchen with wood accent and rattan kitchen stools
These kitchen stools are so versatile and look amazing.

Shop My Favorite Stools For Your Kitchen Island

I’ve replaced my kitchen island stools several times. I love how an easy swap can change the overall feel of your kitchen. 

Take a look at some of the best stools for your kitchen island at an affordable price.

How To Choose The Best Stools For Your Kitchen Island Round Up Of 13 Stools

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13

1

Baxton Studio Sofia Modern Wood Counter Stool

Baxton Studio Sofia Modern Wood Counter Stool
2

POLY & BARK Weave Counter Stool

POLY & BARK Weave Counter Stool
3

Safavieh Home Collection Fremont Natural Barstool

Safavieh Home Collection Fremont Natural Barstool
4

KOUBOO Chippendale Rattan Barstool

KOUBOO Chippendale Rattan Barstool
5

Ball & Cast Kitchen Island Woven Bar Stools Counter Height

Ball & Cast Kitchen Island Woven Bar Stools Counter Height
6

PURPLE LEAF French Counter Height Bar Stool Set of 2

PURPLE LEAF French Counter Height Bar Stool Set of 2
7

Duhome Wood Bar Stools Set of 2

Duhome Wood Bar Stools Set of 2
8

Bar Stools Set of 2, Counter Height

Bar Stools Set of 2, Counter Height
9

Set of 2 Natural Rattan Bar Stools Counter Stool

Set of 2 Natural Rattan Bar Stools Counter Stool
10

25.9-inch Woven Rope Bar Stool

25.9-inch Woven Rope Bar Stool
11

Nathan James Bailey Upholstered Rattan Bar Stool

Nathan James Bailey Upholstered Rattan Bar Stool
12

EALSON Counter Height Bar Stools Set of 2

EALSON Counter Height Bar Stools Set of 2
13

Counter Height Bar Stools

Counter Height Bar Stools

Other Posts You’ll Love

High End Kitchen Cabinet Brands | Kitchen Pendant Lights | Mudroom Lockers

Pin The Photo Below For Later

By considering these factors – size, style, functionality, comfort, quantity, and quality – you can choose the best stools for your kitchen island that will enhance both the look and usability of your space.

With the right bar stools, your kitchen island can become a stylish and inviting gathering place for family and friends alike. Carefully considering your space and style preferences, you’ll find the perfect stools to make your kitchen island the inviting centerpiece of your home.

How To Choose The Best Stools For Your Kitchen Island Round Up Of 13 Stools

xoxo, Arin
Join the Conversation